EVIDENCE LIBRARY

Did Higher Residential Treatment Costs Mean Higher Total Health Costs?

Costs for treatment and costs for other health services are different measures. An Australian MATES cohort sub-study followed 323 participants with methamphetamine dependence who completed three- and twelve-month assessments. It estimated treatment expenditure alongside self-reported health-service use.

Where the costs sat

Mean drug-treatment cost was AU$10,540 per person per year, accounting for much of the mean total health-care cost of AU$16,862. Counselling participants had lower treatment costs than participants in detoxification or residential rehabilitation. The latter groups, however, had lower estimated costs from other health-service use.

Why that is not proof of savings

Participants were not randomly assigned to treatment types. The groups may have differed in illness severity, housing, access or other factors that also affect service use. Costs were estimated using published unit prices and reported utilization, not a controlled experiment showing that one treatment caused a reduction in hospital or emergency costs.

The study supports a more complete accounting: comparing programs by their direct price alone can miss other health-service expenditure. It does not by itself establish the most cost-effective treatment for an individual.

Source: Health care costs among people who use methamphetamine in Australia. Drug and Alcohol Review. doi:10.1111/dar.14043.