EVIDENCE LIBRARY

Why Chao’s 200 Postmortem Cases Undercut a Single Vitreous-to-Blood Alcohol Ratio

Short answer: A postmortem vitreous ethanol result is a measurement of eye fluid, not a direct blood alcohol result. In a 1993 study of 200 postmortem cases, Chao and Lo found different average blood-to-vitreous ratios after grouping cases by their urine-to-blood ethanol ratio. The wide ranges within those groups make a single multiplier a poor substitute for the actual blood result in an individual case.

What question did the study ask?

Chao and Lo compared ethanol in postmortem blood, vitreous humor and urine. Their specific question was whether the relationship between blood and vitreous changed with the apparent stage of alcohol distribution. They used a urine-to-blood ethanol ratio of 1.20 as the dividing point: ratios below that threshold were assigned to an early-absorption group; the other group included later absorption and elimination. This was the authors’ grouping method for their dataset, not a definitive clock for the time of drinking or death in every case.

How different were the two blood-to-vitreous groups?

In the early-absorption group, the authors reported a mean blood/vitreous ratio of 1.29, a range of 0.71 to 3.71, and a standard deviation of 0.57. In the later group, the mean was 0.89, the range was 0.32 to 1.28, and the standard deviation was 0.19. Blood and vitreous are the numerator and denominator in that order. Reversing the ratio would change its meaning.

The group means point in different directions. Early in the paper’s phase classification, blood tended to exceed vitreous. In the later grouping, vitreous tended to exceed blood. Yet the ranges overlap. A particular result cannot be assigned a reliable phase merely because one specimen exceeds the other.

Can the mean ratio convert one vitreous result into a blood result?

The authors described group-level equations, B = 1.29 × V for their early group and B = 0.89 × V for their later group. They also warned that the first relationship could underestimate blood ethanol in very early absorption, while the second could overestimate it in late elimination. Those qualifications matter whenever a calculated blood value is presented as though it had been measured.

For illustration only, a vitreous concentration of 100 units would produce point calculations of 129 or 89 units under the two respective mean ratios. Neither number is an observed blood result in a new case, and neither is an individual prediction interval. The paper’s observed ratio ranges show substantially greater variation than those point calculations convey. A case-specific interpretation should begin with the actual specimen results, units, collection details and analytical records.

What would a reviewer need to evaluate a case?

  • Was the blood specimen peripheral or central, and when and how were blood, vitreous and urine collected?
  • Were all three matrices measured, or is a urine-to-blood phase grouping impossible because one result is absent?
  • Are the reported ratios calculated in the same direction as the study’s blood/vitreous and urine/blood ratios?
  • What are the analytical method, preservation, storage, decomposition findings and possible contamination issues?
  • Is the proposed blood number a laboratory measurement or a model-based estimate, and what individual uncertainty accompanies it?

The study supports a phase-sensitive interpretation of paired specimens. It does not establish a universal conversion factor, the amount consumed, a time of drinking, a driving-time blood concentration or impairment while alive. The 200 observations are historical postmortem cases; applying their group averages to another case requires explicit consideration of comparability and uncertainty.

Scientific source

Chao TC, Lo DST. Relationship Between Postmortem Blood and Vitreous Humor Ethanol Levels. American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology. 1993;14(4):303–308. Based on the user-supplied full paper; DOI was not identified in the supplied copy.