EVIDENCE LIBRARY
What Does It Mean That Only 136 of 1,323 Milan Autopsies Had Toxicology Requested?
Short answer: The 136 toxicology cases were a selected subset of 1,323 autopsies at one Milan bureau during 2018–2019. The paper says analyses were requested when the Judicial Authority sought more information about cause or manner of death. Its percentages describe that referred subset, not every death in Milan or every autopsy at the bureau.
Why does the denominator matter?
The investigators report that toxicology was requested in 10.3% of the 1,323 autopsies. That decision occurred before the analytical findings. A high rate of positive findings among the 136 selected cases would therefore reflect a population already chosen for further investigation. It cannot be converted into the prevalence of drug involvement among all 1,323 cases without examining the untested autopsies.
What did the study actually measure?
The authors assembled clinical history, case circumstances, specimen information and analytical results for the 136 referred decedents. They report 101 positive toxicology cases and describe the substances encountered. Those data can characterize the work performed in that bureau and show how toxicology contributed to selected investigations. They cannot establish a population-wide frequency of poisoning.
How should an expert use it?
State the two denominators each time a percentage is quoted. Ask why toxicology was ordered and whether the comparison group underwent the same testing. Do not mistake referral patterns for biological rates. The paper is a retrospective single-center series, with case selection shaped by the Judicial Authority’s requests and the specimens available for each decedent.
Scientific source
Di Candia et al., Journal of Forensic Sciences (2022), doi:10.1111/1556-4029.15050. Based on the supplied full text.