EVIDENCE LIBRARY

Why Did a Thirteen-Study Alcohol Simulator Review Have Limited Certainty?

The review found alcohol-related deterioration in several simulated-driving measures, but its certainty was limited by the studies it included. Rezaee-Zavareh and colleagues included 13 randomized papers in their qualitative synthesis and classified every one as high risk of bias.

What did the authors review?

The included trials compared simulator performance after alcohol consumption with performance without alcohol. Outcomes included lane-position variability, speed variability, lane crossings and simulated accidents. The review did not pool these outcomes into a single universally applicable driving-impairment number.

Why does bias matter?

Risk of bias concerns how study design and conduct may distort an estimate. The authors also described troublesome heterogeneity, meaning the studies differed enough to make a simple summary difficult. A direction of effect can be informative while its precise size remains uncertain.

How should the review be cited?

Say that alcohol generally worsened selected simulator outcomes in these studies, then disclose the high-risk-of-bias rating and variation. The review does not establish an individual driver’s crash probability or make a simulator metric interchangeable with observed real-road conduct.

Scientific source: Rezaee-Zavareh MS, Salamati P, Ramezani-Binabaj M, et al. Alcohol consumption for simulated driving performance: a systematic review. Chinese Journal of Traumatology. 2017;20:166–172. doi:10.1016/j.cjtee.2017.04.002.