EVIDENCE LIBRARY

Does Refrigeration Alone Stop Ethanol Formation in Postmortem Tissue?

Short answer: Refrigeration at 4 °C did not prevent a large average increase in ethanol in the unpreserved postmortem tissues tested in a Federal Aviation Administration experiment. In that experiment, tissue stored without preservative for 96 hours at 4 °C showed a reported mean relative increase of 1470%. The result demonstrates why “refrigerated” alone is an incomplete preservation history.

What was the experiment?

Johnson and colleagues used unadulterated tissue specimens obtained from fatal aviation accident victims. They compared aliquots prepared with and without sodium fluoride and stored them at 4 °C or 25 °C for up to 96 hours. The question was whether ethanol could form after collection in specimens the laboratory might actually receive. This was a controlled specimen-storage experiment, not a measurement of anyone’s blood alcohol while alive.

What happened without preservative?

At 4 °C, the unpreserved specimens showed an average ethanol increase of 1470% after 96 hours. At 25 °C, the report describes an average increase of 1432% after 48 hours. Those percentages are relative changes within the study. They should not be converted into a fixed mg/dL increase for another case without knowing the starting concentration and the actual analytical measurements.

What did fluoride change?

With 1.00% sodium fluoride added, the investigators reported no significant ethanol increase at either tested temperature. That finding supports the value of preservation under the experiment’s conditions. It does not establish that every preserved specimen, every microorganism or every later storage interval will behave identically.

What should a case reviewer request?

Determine what tissue was collected, whether preservative was present and at what concentration, when it was added, the temperature history and the delay before analysis. Also obtain the original result, any repeat analysis and the condition of the body and specimen. Refrigeration, fluoride and elapsed time are distinct facts; each should be documented rather than inferred from a final concentration.

The FAA experiment shows a mechanism for post-collection ethanol formation and one tested preservation condition. It cannot tell whether a particular decedent drank alcohol or how much of a particular specimen’s ethanol formed after death.

Scientific source

Johnson RD, Lewis RJ, Angier MK, Vu NT. The Formation of Ethanol in Postmortem Tissues. FAA Civil Aerospace Medical Institute final report DOT/FAA/AM-04/4. February 2004. Based on the supplied full report.